Comparing GWT to other Java/AJAX Frameworks

I’ve been using GWT for the past three years on various projects. I still consider it the best Java/AJAX framework on the market, especially when coupled with SmartGWT. However, they are other frameworks that offer similar features. I like to keep a watch on these frameworks to see how they are doing.

Here’s a list of comparable frameworks

Echo2 / Echo3

Blurb from website

Echo is an open-source framework for developing rich web applications. From the developer’s perspective, Echo behaves as a user interface toolkit–like Swing or Eclipse SWT. Visit website: http://echo.nextapp.com/site/

Vaadin

Vaadin is a web application framework for Rich Internet Applications (RIA). In contrast to Javascript libraries and browser-plugin based solutions, it features a server-side architecture, which means that the largest part of the logic runs on the server. Ajax technology is used on the browser side to ensure a rich and interactive user experience. Visit website: http://vaadin.com/home.

Darby note: Vaadin is built on top of GWT.

ZK

ZK is a an Ajax + Mobile framework designed to maximize enterprise operation efficiency and minimize the development cost by its groundbreaking Direct RIA architecture. Visit website: http://www.zkoss.org.

Comparisons

A longer list of frameworks is available here, but most of these the projects are still in early stages, orphaned or have minimal documentation.

I like the features in ZK, Vaadin and Echo2/3. However, it seems to me that GWT has the most support at the moment. As a developer, I like to judge the pulse of the IT industry by checking the jobs boards. Just pay a visit to dice.com and enter the name of a given framework. Count the number of job postings and that should give you a good feel for industry adoption. Also, check the number of books on the topic at amazon.com.

Did you like my blog post?

Signup now and receive an email when I publish new luv2code content.

I agree to have my personal information transfered to AWeber ( more information )

I will never give away, trade or sell your email address. You can unsubscribe at any time.

Leave a Reply